Praise and criticism, the american statistician, american statistical association, vol. The author nassim nicholas taleb defends the thesis that the most improbable events always end up coming. The journal write up also includes important messages and crucial passages from the book. She keeps pulling at extra skin near her finger nail until she tears away at her skin and bleeds. It is unusual for the editors of the american statistician to contribute regular articles to the journal. The term is based on an ancient saying that presumed black swans did not exist a saying that became reinterpreted to. The impact of the highly improbable by nassim nicholas taleb. I read his famous the black swan a while back while in the field and wrote lots of notes. Darren aronofskys black swan is a fullbore melodrama, told with passionate intensity, gloriously and darkly absurd. In his last two chapters, mr taleb draws together the books ideas with some of his previous work. Black swan events are characterized by their extreme rarity.
Talebs book the black swan was a new york times best seller when it came out several years ago. See black swan theory for talebs definition of a black swan event. The historian john mueller s brilliant 1989 book, retreat from doomsday, published just before the berlin wall fell, did see it coming. Jul 21, 2008 i flipped through the second book in the bookstore and thought it was an interesting book, especially for teaching statistics to curious and skeptical undergraduate students. Nassim nicholas talebs 2007 bestseller the black swan. The problem calls into question all empirical claims made in everyday life or through the scientific method, and, for that reason, the philosopher c. Chris anderson, editor in chief of wired, author of the long tail. It centers on a performance by natalie portman that is nothing short of heroic, and mirrors the conflict of good and evil in tchaikovskys ballet swan. Jan 16, 2019 the umeasurability of black swan and the human tendency of discounting their very possibility, is a central tenet in the book. Once upon a time there was a clever young financial professional called nassim nicholas taleb. Taleb, of course, refers to numerous historical examples of things that have come completely out of the blue. The black swan theory or theory of black swan events is a metaphor that describes an event that comes as a surprise, has a major effect, and is often inappropriately rationalized after the fact with the benefit of hindsight.
A central idea in talebs book is not to attempt to predict black swan events, but. Written informally, the notes contain a mesh of quotes and my own thoughts on the book. This book is about the absolutely unexpected, the black swan you would never suspect if you only saw white swans all your life. The impact of the highly improbable paperback 28 feb 2008. Style, and voice in black swan green for david mitchells black swan green, we are told the story through the first person narration of jason taylor. The better angels of our nature is a wonderful bookinsightful, carefully argued and gracefully written. Black swan is ionospherically over the top, and some of its effects are overdone, but it is richly, sensually enjoyable and there is such fascination in seeing portman surrender to the madness and. Putting his definition in the article about his book could eliminate this article, which seems to offer little support for the theory from other sources. This is my book summary of the black swan by nassim nicholas taleb. May 11, 2010 the black swan has appealing cheek and admirable ambition. Broad said that induction is the glory of science and the scandal of philosophy. The black swan is the second volume of his 4volume body of work on uncertainty, called incerto. Apr 22, 2007 the hubris of predictions and our perpetual surprise when the notpredicted happens are themes of nassim nicholas talebs engaging new book, the black swan. Black swan green was the third tale of mitchells that ive read cloud atlas was the first.
Id like to be notified of new arrivals in the following categories. Black swan down nassim taleb explains the power of skin. Ifyouareastatistician,orstatisticallyminded,nassim nicholas taleb really wants to get under your skin. Thoughts on black swans and antifragility monkeys uncle. An analysis of nassim nicholas talebs the black swan. Today, i stumbled over a special issue in the american statistician august 2007 designated to the praises and criticisms mainly the latter of the black swan. The hidden role of chance in life and in the markets, and antifragile. But ultimately, the bumper sticker shit happens is kind of funny, kind of true, but hardly profound. Both the movie and book were very good but, had little in common beyond a boat named the black swan, a evil captain leach, a girl, a charming french pirate, and a floppish englishman. A black swan is a highly improbable event with three principal ch. After meeting with statisticians at a jsm an annual statistical conference, taleb toned down his criticism of statistics somewhat.
Black swan was his fifth fulllength film, and earned him some positive criticism on its controversial themes and ideas. The black swan this book is a philosophical essay on the importance of chance. Anyone who has ever been in a high school production of. This choice of perspective is well within the precedent of young adult literature that was established by j. A black swan is a random, highly unlikely event that it is difficult to predict and that impacts our lives. Apr 27, 2007 the september 11 attacks were a black swan.
Both the movie and book were very good but, had little in common beyond a boat named the black swan. Quoted influentials in order of appearance in the prologue, taleb makes a case against quoting experts to support ones point. I never got around to posting those notes since they were quite telegraphic and often not even electronic. This specificity might seem the opposite of the wrestler, but hear me out. Until the 19th century and the discovery of mutant black swans in australia, it was assumed all swans were white. Dec 03, 2010 the director darren aronofsky is a wellschooled cineaste, and in black swan he riffs on michael powell and emeric pressburgers ballet masterpiece, the red shoes, and the pairs. Swan lake requires a dancer who can play both the white swan with innocence and grace, and the black swan, who represents guile and sensuality. The more skin in the game you have, the greater your exposure to black swans. Praise for nassim nicholas taleb the most prophetic voice of all. Black swan is the type of psychological thriller that tries to catch you off guard by setting it in the seemingly posh and innocent world of professional ballet. If you mean fair in the sense of judiciously weighting the entire work and indicating points of agreement and disagreement, then no. The black swan goodreads meet your next favorite book. Chris anderson, editor in chief of wired, author of the long tail idiosyncratically brilliant. Get a 100% unique essay on psychoanalytic critique on the black swan.
Ballerinas dance in ballets, a famous ballet is swan lake, one of the starring roles of swan lake is the black swan. The film shows nina compulsively harming herself to become the black swan she is trying so desperately to perfect. Taleb is famous not only for being a retired options trader, but also for his books, the black swan. In his last two chapters, mr taleb draws together the book s ideas with some of his previous work.
The impact of the highly improbable is precisely such a book. Is nassim talebs criticism of steven pinkers work fair. Psychoanalytic critique on the black swan free essays. Events like 911, the collapse of longterm capital management and most wars are black swans. The black swan, of nicholas nassim talebs title, describes an event that occurs completely outside expectations, has an enormous impact. The new york public library recently hosted a discussion between two of the current eras leading thinkers about decision making under uncertainty. The black swan has appealing cheek and admirable ambition.
The impact of the highly improbable is a book by the essayist, scholar, philosopher, and statistician nassim nicholas taleb. Black swan is a book about risk and uncertainty presented as a mixture of philosophy and statistics with elements of personal experience. The black swan, with its phallic neck and its feminine body, is also suggestive of the desired sexual union. While black swan wasnt called the ballerina, its nearly the same thing, just more specific. It centers on a performance by natalie portman that is nothing short of heroic, and mirrors the conflict of good and evil in tchaikovskys ballet swan lake. I decided to read this after watching the black swan tyrone powers pirates not natalie portman and tutus. My notes are a reflection of the journal write up above. A black swan is an unpredictable event that is beyond what is normally expected of a situation and has potentially severe consequences. Taleb has made his living and a small fortune, now transformed into a large fortune by the 2008 market in an unusual way by financial speculation in contexts where he spots a small chance of making a very large gain. My advice about reading these books is to read each of them more than once except fooled by randomness. The effort put forth by natalie portman in black swan makes any doubters swallow all criticism and pride with minimal dry heave. The black swan may popularize the concept of low probability events, what were called peso problems see rietz 1988, and that would be a good thing. Although the problem arguably dates back to the pyrrhonism of ancient philosophy, as well as the carvaka.
The book focuses on the extreme impact of certain kinds of rare and unpredictable events outliers and humans tendency to find simplistic. Gq praise for the black swan a book that altered modern thinking. The black swan criticizes society for failing to expect. Aug 14, 2016 i read antifragile first, followed by black swan, bed of procrustes and did not finish fooled by randomness. In what order should nassim nicholas talebs incerto series. The impact of the highly improbable, fooled by randomness. In his 2001 book fooled by randomness, which became a surprise hit in the months after the sept. Kahneman was awarded the nobel prize in economics in 2002 for his pioneering work.
461 655 645 1178 852 1101 1525 1372 595 292 590 64 749 65 115 777 969 1448 221 1231 491 1458 1024 920 207 1168 275 377 1104 770 381 1479 413 877 300